Practical strategies for meaningful music teaching in flexible group settings
By Dennis Frayne
What if you are asked to teach a lesson on an instrument you do not play or a group of students
who are all at different levels? At first, even thinking about planning a mixed-instrument or
mixed-level music lesson can feel daunting.
As music teachers we often define our work through specialization and we take pride in
developing expertise within that area. And we see our students at particular levels: beginners,
intermediate, and advanced. These specializations and assignments are valuable and necessary.
At the same time, they can quietly narrow our sense of what a music lesson can be and of what
we are capable of as music teachers.
It is worth exploring a broader idea: We do not only teach instruments; we teach music.
When we fully embrace this distinction, new teaching possibilities begin to emerge. Lessons no
longer depend entirely on matching instruments or aligning students at the same level. Instead,
they can be structured around shared musical understanding, listening, collaboration, and skill
development that applies to all musicians. From this perspective, mixed teaching settings become
not only manageable, but genuinely valuable.
Designing Effective Mixed Lessons
Most teachers encounter mixed teaching situations at some point.
● A student attends a group make-up lesson.
● A substitute teacher covers a schedule.
● A guest teacher is invited to a school to work with a variety of students or ensembles.
● A private studio teacher coaches a trio of mixed instrumental students to prepare for a
recital yet only plays and regularly teaches one of the instruments.
● A summer or after-school program brings together students of different ages, instruments,
and experience levels.
● In many studios, small group classes occasionally include a guest student who does not
match the primary focus of the class.
● In a school classroom environment, a new student may be placed in a class mid-semester
or mid-year.
These situations can feel like disruptions to an otherwise carefully structured teaching routine
and progression. However, with a shift in perspective, they can become some of the most
musically rich experiences we can offer.
The shift is not about abandoning instrument-specific teaching but about expanding what is
possible within it. It is about increasing our options for handling unique situations and
opportunities. When teachers and students engage with music in multiple ways, everyone’s
understanding deepens, and our connection to what we are teaching and learning can become
more meaningful and lasting.
What if we Don’t Play Their Instrument?
You may be thinking: “It’s one thing to teach students who are not our regular ongoing students
but who are learning our primary instrument. What do we teach when we are working with
students whose instruments we do not play?”
This is the time to recognize the full breadth of musicianship and the full scope of our abilities as
musicians and teachers.
First, avoid approaching the lesson from a perspective of insufficiency or limitation. You are an
accomplished musician and experienced teacher who can teach much in the way of meaningful
musical knowledge and skill to anyone! In addition, have a growth mindset as a teacher who can
learn alongside their students. Do not tell a student or parent, “I don’t play the trombone,” or
“I’ve never taught strings before.” Instead, say, “Today we are going to explore and apply
musical knowledge and skill in ways your child may not have experienced before.”
A well-designed one-time lesson or multi-lesson course or camp can include listening, analyzing,
singing, rhythmic work, clapping and movement, ensemble playing, improvising, discussing, and
performing. It may incorporate elements of music theory, history, culture, and creative work
alongside technical development. Teachers can lead activities in sight singing, ear training, and
musical analysis that directly strengthen a student’s overall musicianship. Teachers can
accompany solo instrumentalists on the piano or have a piano student accompany them on their
solo instrument. These areas are not secondary to their instrumental study; they are foundational:
The music lesson becomes centered on music more generally while still supporting individual
instrumental pathways and skill development.
In this way, the teacher’s role expands naturally. Rather than focusing only on instrument-
specific technique, the teacher becomes a guide in developing the whole musician. Once this
shift occurs, mixed-instrument teaching can become more natural, effective, and enjoyable.
Lesson Structure & Practical Applications
A thoughtful structure is definitely one of the keys to successful implementation. Develop a
structure by thinking in terms of small chunks of time. Balance individual participation with
group engagement and include a variety of musical activities. Short segments, perhaps five to ten
minutes in length, allow for flexibility while maintaining focus. Design activities in a way that
students at different levels can meaningfully participate. A beginner and an advanced student can
both clap rhythms, sing solfege, or identify patterns, with the level of complexity adjusted as
needed. A pair of early intermediate and late intermediate students can play duets or ensemble
pieces where the parts are leveled.
Handouts can play a valuable supporting role in this process. A well-designed worksheet or
reference page can guide an activity during the lesson and give students something tangible to
take home. This reinforces learning, encourages continued engagement, and provides both
structure and a visible sense of purpose. Completed printables and occasional crafts for younger
students can contribute to creative and joyful experiences and also build confidence among
parents and administrators who appreciate seeing concrete materials connected to instruction.
While handouts and crafts do require preparation, they can be reused and refined over time,
becoming an important part of a teacher’s instructional toolkit.
While worksheets can be useful, it is important that music lessons remain musical. Students
should be actively making music, not only completing exercises or practicing in isolation. When
students sing, play, listen, and respond together, the lesson becomes collaborative and engaging.
Over time, this approach helps students develop confidence, adaptability, and a deeper
connection to music.
[A Guiding Principle: Follow the Student
Especially when substituting for a student’s regular teacher or serving as a guest teacher, one
principle remains essential: Follow the student.
When working with students outside of their regular lesson structure, the goal is to support and
reinforce their ongoing learning. Students benefit when their current work is respected and
strengthened. Their regular teacher’s approach should be honored and conflicting ideas should be
avoided.
It can be appropriate to introduce something new in a modest and carefully framed way, but this
is not the time to redirect a student’s long-term path. Introducing new technical approaches or
interpretive ideas can create confusion, particularly for younger or less experienced students.
This is especially important when a student is preparing for a performance. Even small changes
can introduce uncertainty at the wrong moment.
For this reason, a guest-teacher lesson should leave students feeling more secure, more capable,
and more connected to their music than when they arrived.]
Vignette 1: A Lesson That Should Not Have Worked
Following is an example of a possible mixed instrument teaching scenario. A teacher is asked to
lead a small group make-up class including four students: a beginning piano student, an
intermediate violinist, a young singer, and a late-intermediate guitarist. On paper, the lesson
would be difficult to structure in any traditional way.
Rather than separating students or attempting to rotate instrument-specific instruction, the
teacher centered the lesson on shared musicianship and began by having the students establish a
steady pulse through clapping and movement. Each student then performed a short piece while
the others listened. The group discussed phrasing and musical shape using accessible language.
The students and teacher then explored scales together, each on their own instrument, focusing
on tone, dynamics, and rhythmic steadiness. The vocal student sang the scale on solfege and on
note names. They discovered they could all play C Major, and so they engaged in slow practice
together, playing the scale several times, up and down, as an ensemble. This proved more
challenging than anyone initially expected.
By the end of the hour, the students had listened deeply, performed multiple times, and
participated in ensemble-style activities that none of them would have experienced in a standard
private lesson. What initially appeared to be a limitation became a meaningful and memorable
musical experience.
Masterclasses: A Natural Extension
Masterclasses have long been a central feature of music education, particularly in universities
and conservatories, where faculty and guest artists work with students in public settings. In these
contexts, masterclasses often serve as a bridge between private study and performance, helping
students refine their work while gaining insight from the instruction given to others. This model,
however, is not limited to advanced study. When thoughtfully adapted, it can be equally effective
in private studios, group classes, and pre-college programs.
One of the most meaningful benefits of the masterclass format is the opportunity it provides for
observational learning. Students begin to recognize patterns in musical interpretation, technical
challenges, and expressive choices. They develop the ability to listen with greater awareness and
gain exposure to repertoire, instruments, and perspectives beyond their own. Over time, this kind
of listening cultivates musical understanding in ways that individual instruction alone cannot
fully achieve.
Like recitals, masterclasses can be implemented as regular, ongoing events in private studios for
students ranging from beginner to advanced levels.
Vignette 2: Learning by Listening
In one studio masterclass, a series of piano students performed short excerpts from their
repertoire. Among them was a younger student who had not yet developed confidence in
performing. Rather than requiring a full performance, the student was invited to play only the
opening phrase.
Afterward, the group was asked a simple question: “What did you notice?”
The responses were thoughtful and varied. One student commented on the steadiness of the
rhythm. Another described the shape of the phrase. The teacher noted the use of dynamics and
suggested a slight contrast to clarify the musical line.
When the student played the phrase again, the difference was immediate. The playing was more
confident, more shaped, and more expressive. The student had not received an extensive list of
corrections but had instead absorbed a few clear musical ideas through listening and shared
reflection.
Best Practices for Leading Masterclasses
To be effective, masterclasses benefit from thoughtful structure and intentional leadership from
the teacher. While they may appear informal, the most successful sessions are carefully guided to
ensure that all students remain engaged and that learning is continuous throughout.
Begin by setting clear expectations. Students should understand that they are not only
performers but active participants for the duration of the class. Listening is central to the process,
and students should be encouraged to observe closely and reflect on what they hear.
When working directly with a performer, it is often most effective to offer only one or two
focused suggestions for improvement or experimentation. This allows the student to
concentrate on a small number of meaningful changes rather than becoming overwhelmed. After
a brief period of guided practice, the student should perform again, applying the new ideas
immediately. This reinforces learning and allows the group to hear the results in real time.
Keep feedback accessible and broadly applicable. Emphasize rhythm, phrasing, dynamics,
articulation, tone, and musical shape—areas that translate across instruments and levels.
Encourage shorter performances rather than extended works. This allows for broader
participation and maintains energy and focus throughout the session.
Create a supportive and encouraging environment. Students should feel comfortable taking
risks and sharing their work. Feedback should remain constructive and forward-looking.
Incorporate group reflection. Asking students what they noticed and what they might try
themselves fosters active listening and deeper engagement.
Maintain a thoughtful pace by alternating performance, feedback, and discussion. A well-
paced masterclass remains dynamic and engaging from beginning to end.
Final Thoughts
Teaching in mixed settings not only asks us to expand our perspective as educators; it also offers
meaningful rewards. Students develop broader musicianship, increased confidence, and a deeper
connection to music. Teachers gain flexibility, creativity, and a wider range of instructional
tools.
As we move beyond the idea that a lesson must center on a single instrument at a single level, we
begin to see new possibilities for teaching and learning.
In doing so, we return to a simple and powerful idea: We teach music.
Sidebar: 10 Practical Ideas for Mixed Lessons
These activities can be used individually or combined into a complete lesson structure. They are especially effective in group make-up lessons, summer sessions, masterclasses, or regular teaching when you want to incorporate broader musicianship. Many of these activities can be revisited regularly, with increasing levels of depth and complexity.
1. Rhythmic Introductions (“We Will Rock You” Name Game)
Teach the chorus groove of “We Will Rock You” using a steady stomp-stomp-clap pattern, or a seated version with hands on thighs and clapping. Once the groove is established, students sit in a circle and introduce themselves in rhythm: “My name is [Name], I like [something].” Continue around the group, helping students find a natural rhythmic flow if needed. Repeat and vary prompts to build comfort, coordination, and group awareness.
2. Simple Performance Sharing
Each student performs something accessible, even if only a short excerpt. Provide support through duets, accompaniment, or shared performance if needed. Students can also explore performance practice, including walking on and off, responding to applause, bowing, and stage presence.
3. Scales with Purpose
Students play scales individually and together. Focus on steady rhythm, tone, dynamics, and musical shaping. Add solfege or backing tracks to reinforce listening and ensemble awareness.
4. Musical Vocabulary Development
Students learn and review essential musical terms, including definitions, usage, and pronunciation. This can be extended into multiple languages to deepen understanding and context.
5. The Music Alphabet
Students practice speaking the music alphabet forward and backward. Reinforce its connection to the keyboard, staff reading, string instruments where applicable, and melodic direction.
6. Solfege Practice
Students speak and sing movable-Do solfege patterns across different ranges, including stepwise and skipping motion. Reinforce the sound of tonic, dominant–tonic relationships, and the sense of returning “home” to a tonal center.
7. Interval Ear Training
Students compare and identify unison and octave, half and whole steps, and major and minor thirds. This can be expanded to include triads and scales for more advanced students.
8. Rhythm Listening and Analysis
Students identify whether music is in duple or triple meter and determine subdivision. They listen for and recognize recurring rhythmic patterns.
9. Off-Beat and Syncopation Work
Students develop rhythmic independence by clapping on the off-beat and gradually introducing more complex syncopation.
10. Collaborative Ensemble Creation
Students combine instruments, voice, and rhythm to create a short group performance. Assign roles and build a cohesive piece, reinforcing listening and ensemble awareness.